Thursday, February 05, 2009

Moment of Truth

There is this TV show called 'Moment of Truth' on Star world. Apparently it hit the Indian airwaves some time in Nov 1997. It takes a while for such news to reach my little corner in the world and even when it does it takes some more for me to react to it. So it is only natural that I started watching the show only this Monday. It has got to be hugely popular, I am assuming, judging by its nature. Here's a show where people are asked scandalous questions about their private lives, where they bare the dark secrets they hold behind their public image, their extra-marital affairs, felonies and their inner insecurities. There is a polygraph monitoring if their responses or true or false. They have to be truthful if they want the prize money - half a mio if you answer 21 questions truthfully.
Every time the question gets too personal or too embarrassing you can hear a loud collective gasp from the audience but you can also feel the excitement building up about what the answer might be. Questions like:
'Have you cheated on your wife/husband?'
'Do you think you should actually be married to your ex and not to your husband?'
'Have you ever done anything with a co-worker that your husband would not approve of?'

And there are other kind of incriminatory questions like:
'have you stolen anything from your workplace?'
'have you ever flirted with your boss in order to advance your career?
'Have you consumed alcohol when you were pregnant?'

There are seemingly funny but pretty embarrassing questions like:
'have you ever fantasized about sex with a colleague' or 'would you act in an adult film to earn money for college?'
There are no simple questions on this show - at least none without consequences for you unless you have led an exceptionally principled life. As the show host often says the show is trying to see if there is a single honest person left in America.

It is pretty shocking to see the kind of things people are willing to reveal about their personal lives on national television but it is even worse because these are things that the affected people themselves- who are usually their close family and friends- have no inkling about. But isn't this how our lives and relationships are turning out in modern city life? We do not like it if our neighbour wants to know about our personal details but we do not seem to have a problem about sharing the same on a chat show on television or a blog. This is a generation of people who have all been oprahfied that way.

If it is all for the 500,000 dollars, is that the price at which they value their relationships with their family, best friends and their partners that they are willing to accept their darkest secrets that could ruin their relationships with them forever? I am not being judgemental as I am aware that it is a different culture and their relationships are founded on different kinds of arrangements and expectations than the one I am familiar with. And in any case it is their lives. But I talk about the damage to the relationships because one can see the damage right there on their shocked expressions, their stunned head-shakes, their tears of hurt. And oh, how the camera loves it all, lingering on their faces, focusing on their pain! And then the host does the inevitable 'How does that make you feel?' just in case the affected husband/ wife/ mother didn't catch the full import of the damning confession.
TV hosts are the same the world over.*

But the unkindest cut of it all comes when the participant has had a sort of public confession of all their misadventures and finally fails the polygraph test on a simple question like:
'Do you think you are a good person?'
And then she loses the 100 k she has so far won by facing some of the most difficult questions any person has to answer about his/her life.
Or perhaps these are indeed the real moments of truth on the program when a person comes face to face with their own conscience and its muffled voice.

I wish we could have our desi version of the same. While I am not too keen on the dirty linen of private individuals, it would be great if we could make it mandatory for all the candidates contesting the elections for our various legislative assemblies and parliament. Now wouldn't that be fun?



* -(Disclaimer: this statement has nothing to do with any Indian TV host- real or imaginary)

35 comments:

Sri said...

Hi Usha

Enjoyed reading your post...as u said such a programme for politicians would be a wonderful idea!!..Wonder if they could be prosecuted on the basis of this!!!

I am imagining the Paki Government answering questions about Kasab and the Mumbai attacks!

Sri

DC said...

oh! do you think our politicians are that naive? the host of the show will be bribed, the questions fudged and the polygraph tampered, viewers duped and the minister richer by a few more millions!

Anonymous said...

kalakitta Usha... it perplexes me too to see people withholding stuff from their near and dear, but quite willing to talk about it in a public forum ...

now that DC has given away the tricks that a politician will use, let us create a fool proof mechanism and have a show for politicians only .. the only issue is, there wont be any shock or pained expressions from the audience

Chitra

diya said...

Usha, are you sure we WANT to know any such thing about our politicians. We might find that those whom be suspect of commiting one murder, has actually bumped off half a dozen, the chap whom we thought had one extra marital affair has a dozen mistresses stashed away and if we knew the bloke was involved in one scam, we may discover that he has his slimey fingures in every scam since independence! So I think that we are better off not knowing about our politicians it might drive us to commit suicide for it is after all we who bring these scum to power!

litterateuse said...

Never heard of/seen this program - quite a shocker. I think people who have the gall to enter these contests do not have anybody other than themselves on their priority list anyway. Relationships don't matter, they're selfishly going to hurt people around them - might as well run behind an illusory 500k while at it. What's sad is the television guys making suckers out of them.

I think you're being too kind to our politicians. They've become so seasoned at callousness, they will sit through the polygraph, lie through their teeth, chew on paan and come out unscathed.

-gauri

Enchanted said...

Oh.. yes i remember seeing this episode. The girl dressed in agreenish top. Conjeta or something was her name. She answered all the embarrassing questions and failed on the last one "have you ever regretted getting back with your boyfriend" She said No and the answer was yes. She said may be she sometimes thought but that was not how she actually felt. I didnt know if i should feel bad for her or think she deserved it. She even answered questions like did she cheat on her boyfriend and did she flirt with her boss with hopes of advancing her career in affirmative.
I too thought at that time what would happen if this show comes to India. I think they will have to stick to not so personal questions, else no one will participate or may be they will. Money can make a person do anything.

LOL @ your disclaimer about TV hosts. Are u playing safe after the recent reporter-blogger fiasco?

ugich konitari said...

I've never seen this program, and am certainly not besotted with the idea of watching it. But should this ever be implemented in our society, and politicians made to appear on it, I am sure India will be a great place for manufacture of false polygraphs which you can "set" to your liking. ...

Artnavy said...

the disclaimer as the best!!

i watched the show once but really could not stand it and i wonder if the lie detector really works

Poonam said...

Reality shows are fast becoming about taking your dirt linen out in public. Producers work hard to show your dirty linen even if contestants are not so keen. Their logic: TRPs, and people want it.

So despite the likes of us who hate it and would equally watch a simple, not-so-hyped program, there are many who would rather watch this. :(

Solutions? We dont have any unless there are any reality-show loyalists amongst us.

http://alchemistpoonam.wordpress.com

shilpa said...

Well written..
It is amazing..how people will go to any lengths to make money ..from spilling their guts on national TV to betraying their own family.I guess thats why reality Tv does so well these days..that and our morbid fascination for other people's lives

Pramod said...

Very nice post. You make some very good points. Besides the fact that people are willing to sell their relationships for 500k, I think it's also a bit sad that people want to watch this kind of emotional porn. What's this voyeuristic pleasure in watching relationships crumble?

ramya said...

I have seen many episodes of this show. It is so really horrible. How can one answer such non-answerable questions which affect their relationships a lot. I beg to differ from you in having this show in India. Remember questions in Dus Ka Dum - "How many percentage of men sleep during their first night"? It is surely cheap! I have seen some most cheapest and horrible questions on this show and I simply hate it! It horrible to see people crying after answering those question.

But, I have never mentioned before - I am a big fan of your blogs. You write really well! :-)

Pixie said...

yea.... I found the game show a bit ridiculous too and I don't watch it... its being aired 3 nights a week I think.

WhatsInAName said...

The truth is that I simply dont believe in ANY of these reality shows. They are hardly real and somehow most of the times, they are just rehearsed stuffs.
But you are right about one thing. Those who hesitate to share things with their friends and families do so, so easily over the net! Its actually disturbing.
Coming to the politicians, you never know, they may even bribe or buy the polygraph monitoring system!

Unmana said...

You know, I only watched this once, and then I thought I should go on it! well, I don't have much to hide, so it should be easy money!

anamika said...

"We do not like it if our neighbour wants to know about our personal details but we do not seem to have a problem about sharing the same on a chat show on television or a blog."
- you nailed it! LOL!

immemory said...

oui, trés drôle
je ne sais pas
la politique
l'argent
un drole d'épisode

Jane Turley said...

I'm not a fan of this kind of show and have little respect for those who would prostitute themselves in such a way for money... to me this sort of behaviour is much worse than your previous post about the student selling her virginity. To do this type of show (assuming it's a genuine set up) you must either very greedy and selfish (considering the potential to inflict hurt on others) or so poor that you'd do anything for a fast buck.

Shows like this are a sad indictment of our failing society.

mystic_life said...

wow, I think this is worse than any we have here. There is one that comes close, called "real world??" but only because they put such imbalanced people on the show, and you see the ugliness they hold inside after a bit of time.

The whole thing just leaves a bad taste in my mouth.

Art said...

i heard from sometime back..its coming to India... but whats the point.. y would we want to know other's dirty secrets... and does it make sense to say it all in public for money

Praveen said...

Ekta Kapoor might want to grab the rights for the Indian version.
Drama, Natakbazi, and make beleive..just to grab TRPs!
I think I have learnt a lot about Television business now!

Mama - Mia said...

firstly LOL at the disclaimer! :p

and yes, as long as its for our candidates, its quite cool. frankly i dont like reality shows much. there ois just too much money riding on naked emotions and it just seems so unhealthy!

fortunately / unfortunately i dont have cable TV at home! ;)

cheers!

abha

Anonymous said...

isn't this nothing but the zennith of absolute capitalism? With due apologies to Adam Smith, here's a classic case of individual self interest (for money) promoting society's interests (for entertainment) ...
the thought of switching on the tv can be a nightmare ...

- sid

MK said...

Agree with DC on this though, all systems are meant to be broken and politicians will.

However, what captured my imagination is the fact that people are willing to blog initimate details about thier personal life. I think the anonymity of the web actually makes people free. Which also goes to show that people think one thing, talk another and act differently on the same issue. hence the need for anonymity while blogging.

Anyway the willingnes to do such a show is direclty proportional to the perceived need for money. It is true anywhere in the world.

Mahadevan said...

"Everything has a price', it seems to justify. Is it that the opportunity to win a global TV contest earning in the process half a million dollars, would legitimise the wrongs one had been covering up - a sort of disclosing the sinful gains and getting tax reprieve?

The organisers of such shows believe, and I share their belief, that to win prise money, some of the participants would do or reveal anything that would provide sensation to the viewers and add to the coffers of the promoters.

We need Oliver Cromwells to stop bull-baiting.

hillgrandmom said...

Never heard of this program. Sounds sad. Like Jane says, you either have to be really poor or have a deep deep-seated need for publicity, so that nothing else matters. It seems like so many people want their minutes of 'fame' however ugly the consequences might be.

dipali said...

I tried seeing this once after my sister told me about it. Couldn't sit through it- it just seemed too stressful to watch.
By the way, you are tagged.

STALAG SUKHOI said...

yup ,i dont think u will ever find a politician in that pgm [:)]

Just Like That said...

LOL at the disclaimer. Wise, that, in these times. :-)
I wonder how someone comes up with these ideas?
And what kind of people consent to be part of these shows? Whether they have an ounce of sincerity in their bodies?
But maybe there would be plenty of viewers in India if the respondents were Bollywood/other stars. I doubt if anyone believes ANY politician worth his salt would ever say the truth about anything.

Just Like That said...
This post has been removed by the author.
maami said...

These kind of reality shows are embarrassing and gross. It's a sign of our times too- we say 'value individual freedom'- it's their life, they can well make an exhibition of it, but it turns out to be a travesty of personal liberation and leaves a bad taste in the mouth.

Usha said...

Sri: Thanks.
But with paki governement they are too used to lying that they themselves are confused between truth and lies and the polygraph will have a break down!

DC:Yes,I under-estimated out politcians, didn't I!

Chitra:Ya we all want to have our page 3 moments I guess. So we are willing to bare it all ( i mean soul wise) on camera.

Diya:I agree. As I said I seem to havae had a moment of weakness there and under estimated our Politicians.

Litterateuse: The same relatives who cry and sound pained urge the contestant to go on playing. Wonder what kind of masochism it is!

Enchanted; Yes, I saw it too.In India they will rig it.

Ugich:Hahaha. Necessity, the mother of innovation and all that or Jugad?

Artnavy: Heheheh@ disclaimer. Why wait for a few days, get threatened and disclaim? do it right away.

Poonam:I am surprised that our TRP driven channels have not already floated this program. Perhaps there aren't many with so much dirt in their private lives . We might soon have a desi version, all rigged. For 5 crores there would be people willing to manufacture some dirt.

Shilpa:Absolutely.

Pramod:You said it - it is another kind of schadenfreude?

Ramya: Oh no, I was advocating the show only for Politicians. and it aint gonna happen.

Pixie:yes, it is.

WIAN: Ya, I thought it might be rigged too. How can every body have such 'colorful' lives?

Unmana: Guess what, you might never get selected because what would they do with a life that is so scandal-free?

Anamika: !! :)

Immemory: C'est Vrai. je suis d'accord.

Jane: I felt the same as your last line there when I first saw the episode.

Havah; it is the American show that is being telecast here for us to lap up.

Art: Apparently there are people who think that it all makes sense.

Praveen: We will put you on the show and ask you to reveal all the murk about TV business!

Abha: I think most of the time it is fortunate!

Anon: Showing off your eco fundas here. hmmmm.
Ya sometimes it is quite depressing to switch on that TV - news channels, reality shows. All this 'entertainment' gets a bit much.

MK: I agree sometimes it is the comfort of anonymity that makes us feel bold to talk about things that we may not with our real neighbours.
But there are a lot more who enjoy 'confess'ing on their blogs.

Mahadevan:As long as there is an audience these producers will give you'anything' you want.

Hillgran: Ya, that seems to be the case indeed.

Dipali:I found it stressful too. Will pick up the tag soon. :)

Stalog: Me neither. Just wishful thinking!

JLT: :)

Maami:Your comment and Jane's say it all in anutshell.

amreekandesi said...

I have seen this show...and its quite scandalizing!

These people risk their relationships for not a lot of money, and it completely sucks for them if at the end they lose their wife and end with no money either!

It really is a question of how important money is for you. A question of putting a value on life itself, almost.

workhard said...

That would be pretty interesting to see a politician up there and then have his guts spilled out, it should be made mandatory since most of them anyway want to be on tv


Work from home

Meg said...

I've never heard of that show, but I bet I could go on it! Any secrets I have are of the mildly embarrassing kind, not the the life-changing kind. I've not cheated or broken any laws, and I'd totally tell the world I had naked thoughts about inappropriate guys for half a million dollars! I can't imagine why anyone w/ real secrets would want to go on, though.